Archive for ‘Koltreg On Comics’

37 results.

Posing and Figure

by Koltreg on August 13, 2011 at 12:04 am
Posted In: Behind The Scenes, Koltreg On Comics

Kelly Turnbull aka Coelasquid has been tumblring up a storm, making it rain tumblrs, etc recently with her image of the Justice League following Wonder Womans pose and clothing style here.
Coelasquid, who is a friend of the site, recently did a brief interview here where she basically said not every female character needs to be seductive. She goes into greater depth so check out the full article, retumblr the post here as well
but

If it makes people feel any better, I also wish they would give Flash a sprinter’s build, Aquaman a swimmer’s build, Batman an MMA build, and Superman a weightlifter figure compared to that unilateral “this is that one body every superhero artist knows how to draw” look they all have now.

I am totally going to toot my own horn and Remus’ because we did a pretty solid job at a variety of character forms. For example this initial picture of the Justice Society of America in form only.

Capitalist, Bearman, Libertyger, Democrosee, Liberteen and Bullman

 

 

 

 

 

 

Alternately these silhouettes of the members of Socialfist.

 

 

 

 

Not only do each show a different type of strength or at least health but they are all varied.

Also unrelated side note, the one female character currently introduced, Adelichka, almost (joking) ended up like this.

blame Blazel

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Which is wrong on so many levels

That is all for now so go and read and draw some comics.

└ Tags: , , , ,
  Comment

Toonseum’s Blogger Blast II

by Koltreg on August 6, 2011 at 2:05 am
Posted In: Blog, Koltreg On Comics

As I might be called to do when tempted with free things, I visited the Tonnseum’s Blogger Blast 2 this evening and had a wonderful time. I got to go as a blogger (see this site as well as DC Versus Marvel and the now mostly defunct Koltreg blog for blogging credentials).
For those unfamiliar, the Toonseum is the downtown Pittsburgh museum of comic and cartoon art. Recently they have been doing an exhibition on superhero art with a lot of classic pages of art on display (like original Batman, Kirby and Ditko work!) as well as cartoons on the television and a rather informative but brief history, though some sort of tags noting the artists and the issue number of the comics would have been nice.
The Blogger Blast is their way to get the Pittsburgh blogger community, or outside of Pittsburgh community, to start talking about what they will be doing while also getting bloggers to meet up. From the conversations I had, I seemed to be the only comic blogger but I didn’t speak with everyone, though it did generally feel like the community event/hidden gems of Pittsburgh blog crowd as opposed to straight up comics.
This is not to say that I lacked any discussion of comics. Joe Wos the Toonseum director was happy to talk about comics and I also entered into a discussion about webcomics and print with a few other guests which is always fun. Hopefully I can meet some at the upcoming events.
Amongst the upcoming events mentioned there is going to be a giant replica of the Mouse Trap (ala the board game) over at the Carnegie Science Museum which looks good. Additionally a crowd controlled “Geek Night” sounds equally fascinating with events ranging from watching tv and movies to video games and whatever the community would like to do. There will also be an exhibition of some new artists in the area and generally if you live in the area, you will want to check it out.
The other big news was that of an expansion of the Toonseum to encompass the next door building (if you know where Mahoney’s is, they are getting the statue lot area). This will allow more shows like the upcoming 9/11 Comic Remembrance show, a display of Looney Tunes art and more!
The Toonseum has a lot going for it so if you can fit in a trip when you are in Pittsburgh next time, do it! It is a fun place for the whole family to visit.
The website for the Toonseum can be found at http://www.toonseum.org/index.html.

└ Tags: , , , ,
  Comment

Quick Piece On The New Ultimate Spider-man [SPOILERS]

by Koltreg on August 2, 2011 at 7:51 pm
Posted In: Koltreg On Comics

If you didn’t hear the news about Ultimate Spider-man [SPOILERS] he is half black/half Hispanic and is named Miles Morales. The news got released last night and I am happy. I mean I totally said black Spider-man last week (though I am not surprised).

But what does it mean?
Nothing? Progress? Pandering?

I don’t care. I just want to read the comic. ‘Nuff said.

  Comment

4 Comic Characters Without Important Racial Definition

by Koltreg on July 25, 2011 at 11:03 pm
Posted In: Koltreg On Comics

As I prepare to deal with a rush of hatemail and commentary, I want to spell out my stance for these upcoming articles.
With the DC Reboot and I’ll say the Marvel Ultimate Universe as well, you have a chance where you could retcon the races of characters to add more diversity. As it has been seen so far, the only non-white member of the Justice League is Cyborg and my god is he a horribly token character. How token? – the DC Direct Justice League figures didn’t include him. He is replacing J’onn Jo’nzz, the alien-y alien on the classic team line up.
The thing is for most characters, their race is never an issue except in really really awkward moments. Race is something that is still important in the world and it is something people forget about but most comic characters have no racial definition. This isn’t bad. Looking at British TV (since I marathoned Doctor Who) I noticed they had black characters without it being an issue, without stereotypes who were just characters where race never came up. Valve does a good job creating characters without stereotypes or the normal stereotypes at least. The thing is, if this is the case, I believe we could have more minority superheroes replacing all of the white ones without it being important or it could be used for more racial definition.

I did feel like I needed to set a set of rules for this as well.

Rules –
This can’t be a title passed down often commonly (i.e. more than once). For example – Robin, Doctor Fate, The Flash
Must be able to make sense historically. For example – Captain America would not be black due to still shaky stance of African Americans during WW2.
It must racially make sense – For example – having Black Panther be a white guy wouldn’t make sense.
It can’t be tied directly to mythology. For example – avoiding the Heimdall scenario in Thor and Thor: The Mighty Avenger.
No teams. For example Green Lantern, X-men. They will naturally have at least 1 non-white member.

Ant Man/Hank Pym – Hank Pym, when it comes down to it, is a scientist with stress problems and mental issues and he is a pretty liberal and nonviolent person. He makes bad choices, uses his powers for selfish reasons. He doesn’t care as much about class and really believes in making the world a better place. Race has no place in his identity so perhaps making him Arabic which might make some of his background more interesting. When he makes Ultron that would raise more doubts about trusting him more than I think they ever did in Ultimates.

Spider-man – Spider-man is a kid with spider powers who believes that with great power comes great responsibility. He gets picked on for being nerdy, smaller and being really un-atheletic. Making him black for example would make the character have the cultural issues added in, an aunt and uncle who would have most likely been involved in the civil rights movement and it would be an opportunity for Don Glover to be Spider-man.

Superman – Superman was lucky that Kryptonians look human. And white. I mean imagine in a black kid came from a space ship. Or an insectioid. Or if he wasn’t as attractive as he is. If Superman weren’t white he’d have a harder battle for trust (because for the average American, they just think everyone besides Lex Luthor loves Superman). Were he not white it would be nowhere as easy.

Aquaman – Loosely scientifically speaking if Aquaman lived underwater, it wouldn’t make sense for his skin to be white. Considering that in the water his skin would stick out it makes even less sense and this race has been around for thousands of years. That is time for evolution to occur. It would make sense for more blue skin and sure you could argue his curse made him look more white but why not make him another color, to have another culture. Oh, an his mom was Inuit so that would also make his skin a different color. Bam!

Give the characters a new starting point by adding diversity, a way to make heroes appeal more. Right now there isn’t much of that and it may be part of the American culture but it doesn’t need to be that way.

Join next time for 4 Comic Characters Not Defined By Gender

Note: Also on the list I came up with but not fleshed out – Catwoman, Rorschach, Zatanna, Dr Strange, Constantine and The Punisher.

Can you think of others? Comment below? Am I missing out on some majorly important racial storyline? Comment below.

2 Comments

No Post Title

by Koltreg on July 25, 2011 at 4:27 am
Posted In: Koltreg On Comics

If there is one superhero movie I am waiting for now, it is The Amazing Spider-man. More than The Dark Knight Rises. More than The Avengers. More than Superman.

Nolan did an amazing job on the first two Batman films and they are great films but I don’t want to watch them on repeat. Ironman 1 and 2 I liked but once again but I can’t watch them on repeat. The last movie I could watch on repeat was Scott Pilgrim Vs The World and I had days where I watched the movie 3 or 4 times in a row. That is a movie I love and enjoy and it is a good, fun film. I want that in Spider-man. I don’t want grim and gritty because Spider-man isn’t that when he is written correctly.

The Amazing Spider-man has a strong team inspiring confidence for me. The director did 500 Days of Summer and I think he can make the film look and feel different from other superhero films. Emma Stone looks wonderful as Gwen Stacy and she should be more interesting that Mary Jane was. And then there is Andrew Garfield who is not only a strong actor. He also gets Spider-man. If you didn’t see Andrew Garfield’s speech at Comic Con, check it out here along with Adam WarRock’s new song Andrew Garfield at SDCC. Andrew Garfield showed me that he understand Spider-man from that speech. He gets being picked on in a way I don’t think Tobey Maguire ever did. He looks nerdy and scrawny and the way Peter Parker should be. He’s going to be a real kid (though he’solder than me) playing this kid who wants to do the right thing. That is Spider-man.

The universe also seems to be a lot more open. I mean, I enjoyed Raimi’s films but they never covered why he lived with his aunt and uncle. Peter Parker never really showed his smarts which was part of his character. In the new movie, they have mechanical web shooters that he made (which makes me wonder if they’ll retcon Spider-man being eaten and then birthed to have genetic ones in the comic – see #5 ).

Still this is all up in the air. It could be horrible. I could be wrong put Andrew Garfield and Spider-man make me want to believe and I do. Go Spider-man. Go.

  Comment

Reboot Your Attitude

by Koltreg on July 24, 2011 at 3:47 pm
Posted In: Koltreg On Comics

I decided I am giving up on reboot anger because I never really cared about the mainstream DC universe. I’ve said before I never really read comics until a year or so ago. If this bothers you, feel free to stop reading because ultimately if there is something you don’t like that is your choice and that attitude hurts others in the end.

I got into comics with Dark Horse and Hellboy even though I loved the Marvel and DC cartoons I grew up with. When I finally got to reading Marvel and DC stuff even though I had the free opportunity to read anything working at a comic shop, I didn’t. I asked for advice and more often than not people were more likely to tell me what to avoid. They’d like things a bit but they hated other things they’d given up. “Oh yeah, I used to like Teen Titans but then it got bad.” “How long ago did it get bad.” “Three years ago.” “Do you still read it.” “No. It’s rubbish.” The people telling me what not to try made me never try comics. Three months in I started using the excuse that there was too much to read (though that is totally true).

Let me drop in a side story. Growing up my parents hated rap. They’d change the channel if it came on. They avoided it. Now I love the stuff, to a point. I was told Doctor Who was shit and I have spent the entire last week watching the entire series because I really enjoy it. Up next is Torchwood because I want to give it a try. People who say what I might like or not like can be wrong and I need to give it a try.

So now we sit on the precipice of a company wanting to try something new, to save itself and to get new readers. We have yet to open an issue and people are calling it shit. The thing is though, these people writing and drawing the comics believe at least somewhat in what they are making. They like doing what they do for a living. In fact, I doubt there are any creators who are saying “You know what I want – I want to make Batman or whoever so shitty that nobody will want to read him!” The people are trying to save the characters they love and that you love. I want to help them.

I’m going to trust these artists to make good work and I’ll judge after it starts. I sure as hell wont buy everything but if it looks good I’ll give it a shot. If I hear good things, I’ll give it a shot. If I hear shit about it, I still might because people can be wrong. Everyone has different tastes and appeasing all of them is impossible. That is why we have so many flavors. Just do a favor though, don’t call someone else’s favorite flavor shit because it sounds bad. They like the flavor for a reason and might like it too.

└ Tags: , , , , , , , , ,
  Comment

My Turn For A Tired Rant

by Koltreg on June 15, 2011 at 5:35 am
Posted In: Koltreg On Comics

Oh man I have not blogged here in a while because between moving, quitting my job to freelance and everything else my mind has been distracted so let’s talk about comics once more.

Chris Sims at Comics Alliance wrote a great article about trying webcomics as a new medium for major publishers. It worked for Warren Ellis and Freak Angels and there are plenty of popular webcomics that could do very well with support from the online community.

Personally I never read comics until my senior year and that was because I chanced to encounter Lobster Johnson and I had money. Before that I had no comic store growing up so comics besides the newspaper stuff was not in my life.

Webcomics though I have always read since about 2004 or so when a friend introduced me. Before I got my comic shop job I had more webcomic and print collections that comic comics and I also had additional merch.

Webcomics are a great way to try new things or to get the attention of the internet. You know why? For years I was on forums saving images from comics onto my comic art file because I enjoyed bits of the comics. I knew the characters from tv and everything else. We have people who never read Superman getting upset over him non-canonically giving up his citizenship.

So here is the other thing. If you have webcomics for free people have no excuse to avoid comics. I mean, I hate the excuse that people don’t want to get into dealing with canon. There are plenty of comics with non canon they can read, there are plenty of stand alone comics out there with established characters and there are plenty of new series.

If you want to get a friend to like comics, give them Nextwave, give them Runaways, give them Hush or the Long Halloween, give them Super Pro K.O, Crogan’s Vengeance or Fables. There are tuns of stand alone works they can enjoy if you reach out. Share what you love and you make new comic readers.

this goes for comic companies as well. Sure people value free work less but there wouldn’t be webcomic artists making a living off of what they do if there weren’t fans willing to support them. Here is the other thing too, if you make a free comic with a quality team and a big name character online, millions of people will read it. If it is good, they will read more. If they really like it they will try other stuff.

Give them samples of work, show what you can do and share your talent pools with the people who want to swim. That’s how you survive.

  Comment

Action Comics 900 Controversy

by Koltreg on April 30, 2011 at 7:19 am
Posted In: Koltreg On Comics

Action Comics 900 had controversy that actually mattered.

If you didn’t learn about the big kerfuffle that doesn’t matter here it is:
Superman flies overseas to stand in solidarity with people revolting against the government.
Superman does this and he is an American symbol.
Superman also is essentially a nuclear warhead in terms of power.
This is like America sending a nuclear warhead to the protest with no warning.
Superman stands still in solidarity for 24 hours.
The country he flew to sees this as an act of war.
The UN sees this as a US action.
The US says “Let us solve this.”
Superman meets with a government person.
Superman says “Let’s avoid this in the future. I acted on my own. I’ll explain it and give up my citizenship.” (Did he ever actually become a US citizen as Superman?”
Superman hates American, burns a flag, kills the president and goes evil.
Terrorists win.
Every other superhero in the country is unable to stop all the crime.
The criminals open a portal into our world and destroy it.
We are fucked. Thanks a lot additional back story.

Yeah, Superman wants free reign, he doesn’t want to be viewed as a tool for any country and he doesn’t want America to be held accountable for his actions. If you paid attention to the New Krypton thing, Superman left Earth, presumably forever, to live with his own people. No protests then. That was a two year storyline that never made the news. Superman came back when his people tore themselves apart because they were being played against each other over petty human things.

If you still don’t get it.
1 Superman = 100 nuclear bombs
if you flew 100 nuclear bombs to a protest outside of a government that is seen as cruel and evil that would be seen as an act of war.
Superman did that. Superman is seen as an American. Therefore, act of war.

All in all though, this was a backup feature. This could be noncanon. There was another one where Superman and Lois had a party with the Legion of Superheroes. IT DOESN’T MATTER IN THE LONG RUN. Superman giving up citizenship isn’t big either. Let it go. Non-canon. Blap! Blap! Blap!

No, the real controversy happened in the main story of Action Comics. Spoilers ahead.
Lex Luthor has been hunting these Black Spheres.
Luthor is able to channel them to make him a god.
Luthor sends Doomsday (the guy who killed Superman) to fight the rest of the Super Family.
Superman meets up with Luthor.
Luthor finds he can’t plain kill Superman.
Luthor takes Superman back through every tragedy in his life.
Luthor discovers Clark Kent is Superman.
Luthor gets angrier because he doesn’t think Superman has the right to be Clark Kent.
Luthor is told he is losing powers due to trying to do evil with them.
Luthor makes everyone perfectly happy and peaceful for about 2 minutes.
Luthor’s hate distracts him and he loses all the power.

Luthor is not fully evil. He ultimately wants to have Earth succeed. Sure, it is with him as the ruler but when you leave out his vendetta with Superman, Luthor is an amazing person. He is personable, intelligent and he rocks baldness like no other.
In this comic though, Luthor gives up on his dream of ruling the helping everyone because he can’t let himself get past this grudge. That is my beef.
Luthor brings Death (of the Endless happiness). Darkseid would have given up on the Anti-Life Equation. The Joker is even happy.
Luthor is a guy with indomitable will. He will do anything for his desires but his grudge destroys everything he could have ever wanted. That is my problem with Action Comics #900 – Luthor not being able to be a better man than a man who isn’t human.

└ Tags: , , , , , ,
3 Comments

3 For Hollywood

by Koltreg on April 13, 2011 at 5:55 am
Posted In: Koltreg On Comics

Hollywood is invading the comic racks for better or worse and luckily they are, like always, branching out into the third parties like Oni Press, Image and more for new shows and movies. The good and the bad though is when companies/producers don’t know what to expand into. Sure another Batman series of films might be nice but we may be burnt out after the third Nolan film no matter how good it is and since they are proposing a reboot – I am disturbed. So this week I present 3 print comic series that should be adapted in tv shows or films.

Orc Stain – Orc Stain is one of my favorite series out right now that started back up last week (you can pick up all the prior back issues in the first trade). For those who never read my earlier rants about the comic Orc Stain is a comic about a fantasy realm with tons of orc tribes fighting one another. In the meantime an orc tzar has begun rounding up all one eyed orcs and the main hero happens to be an orc named One Eye who has a penchant for safe cracking (to him though, everything is a safe and the cracking part means “breaking in half”).
The series so far excels at chaotic battle scenes, fun gore and violence and vibrant colors. It it were to be adapted into a series by anyone, it would have to be 1. in the future when the series has more to it and 2. adapted by Augenblick Studios or Titmouse Inc, both teams who have worked on Superjail!).
It would probably run better on a network like HBO where there would be less censorship since there is a lot of dick chopping, sex and basically stuff that most late night channels would even take issue with and even then it would only be a cult show but the fans would love it.

Knight and Squire – Sure, Knight and Squire is a DC comic but it is a very British comic. Knight is essentially Tony Stark as the son of Batman. He’s had rough spots but now he fights crime in a mechanical armored suit along with Squire, a girl with the ability to communicate incredibly well. In the mini-series by Paul Cornell the series essentially made a Morrison-boner inducing continuity addition of hundreds of new characters in England.
The show would have to be done by the BBC because it is a very British series and without a doubt American studios would not be able to do it right. Do it low budget, campy to a point with that inescapable factor that makes British television so entertaining.

Fear Agent – Rick Remender’s series Fear Agent about an intergalactic exterminator has the makings of a big film. A gruff space man, an attractive female side kick and lots and lots of killing without all that confusing science.
In a future where Earth has been destroyed, Texan Heath Huston is the last Fear Agent, a group of intergalactic Earth exterminators. After weathering so much Heath stopped giving a damn about rules and regulations and finds shooting and killing his liver are the last bits of solace.
It is fun, action packed and darkly humorous and would make a great film.

I originally had 2 more for the list but I forgot to write them down, it is Wednesday and I totally mind blanked on this.

└ Tags: , , , ,
  Comment

Punch It Sucker

by Koltreg on April 4, 2011 at 7:25 pm
Posted In: Koltreg On Comics

We live in the golden age of pandering. No matter what your quirk, interest or fetish you can find it online. In the best of times it brings together people who both shared interests and then produce quality work. In the worst case events we end up hurting our culture because the way were are pandered to is bad but those in the target demographic don’t care. We get the same games recycled over and over about overly beefy space marines. We get songs about bitches and hoes and partying. We have parts of culture that I worry may be part of some underlying plot to dumb us all down to when shit gets worse, we don’t notice it and then the rich will just use us as energy like some sort of plutocratic Matrix. I’d want to watch that movie but I doubt we’d ever get that.
Thanks to Roger Ebert’s Twitter, I just finished reading an angry blog post about how all the geeks and critics who didn’t like Sucker Punch are ungrateful and they just hate Zack Snyder. (I took my notes and thoughts and I read the article and I’ll post them at the end). I have some beef with the Zack Snyder I will not deny. I am not his biggest fan but I will sure as hell give him a chance if the previews look good. With that said though, I saw the Sucker Punch and I was pretty bored with it. It had bad flow, it had uninspired and stilted dialogue and the story was pretty lax in the end. It also made barely any sense.
If you aren’t familiar with Sucker Punch at all it is about a 20 year old girl who apparently stopped learning to dress herself after she turned 12 so she still wears pigtails. She is about to get raped since rape makes everything serious and adult. When she tries to shoot the rapist who is her step-dad, she shoots her sister and then gets put in an insane asylum. This is all put to music. She could be put in the insane asylum for the pigtails which for me is much more insane, especially since she doesn’t start off as a hooker and the setting is something around the 40s or the 50s. All the while she apparently never tries to tell the police about her step dad raping her or the fact that he’ll get her part of the will. Like seriously if she were to say “Hey this asshole tried to rape the pigtails off of me,” she might have a case. If she said “I accidentally shot my sister when this guy tried to rape the pigtails off of me,” she might have a case. Alternately “I wonder why I ended up killing my sister who I loved which would write me out the will so my step father who tried to rape me will get everything instead since he was left with nothing.” Instead she gets quiet which I can just barely accept, I mean there is no court case to my memory and then she goes to a crazy house where she starts tripping balls. She imagines that her and everyone else are dancer-prostitutes and she figures out a plan to escape before she is set to be lobotomized. So for her quest she needs to collect four items hidden around the asylum. Luckily her dancing makes all the people watching her distracted so her cohorts can steal what they need. Also while she dances she trips balls even deeper and thinks she is a soldier fighting 1. giant demon samurai 2. Nazi clockwork zombies 3 a dragon and orcs and 4. robots. The demon samurai are for her training mission and then everything else she fights is to collect the items even though they collect the stuff in the first and second levels of reality and all she does is dance which we never see. Then drama happens, the warden-esqe guy finds out, people die for real and then the ending comes and I won’t spoil it.
So without the fantasy scenes you’d have a movie about a crazy girl with pigtails who goes into an asylum and gets raped and tries to escape getting lobotomized. Genius! Obviously nerds love to see this – except they wouldn’t. So how do we appeal to the nerds? You make the crazy girls dress up like a burlesque show where they aren’t acting crazy. I wonder if this is due to fear of giving people boners for crazy asylum girl. Then you make them dress up like stripper soldiers. You give them giant demon samurai for her to fight. You add in Nazi clockwork zombies. You make none of these action scenes work together and it looks pretty all while you do it. Pandering.
Now I am not going to complain about the visuals. The designs for everything in the movie looked pretty awesome. Sure it was Nazi clockwork zombies but they were made to look good. Of course, why were they there? Pandering. The dragon looked pretty realistic but in a day and age where you a budget this big, if the graphics don’t look real you are doing something wrong or you are unfamiliar with the uncanny valley. But why have the dragon and the Nazi clockwork zombies? Geeks stereotypically like it. Look at the steampunk, look at all the games where we still kills Nazis (well not me, I still have a Gamecube).
In the article I linked to, the writer brings up Hellboy. Hellboy has a clockwork Nazi zombie. That clockwork Nazi zombie has a point though. He has an origin. He has a reason for being there in the story more that just it was like that in the comics. Hellboy 2 had the Golden Army that was magical old school robots that had a reason in the story. Basically the difference is having a reason for the stuff you put in, making it fit in the universe and making it go with the story. Sucker Punch didn’t do this. Why does this crazy pigtails girl imagine all of this crazy shit? How the hell does she even know what samurai are? I am fairly certain at the time samurai aren’t the hip part of culture with the whole Japanese in WW2 thing.
It could have made sense though. For example if the Nazi clockwork zombies owned the dragon the story would make more sense. You could also have more Nazi clockwork zombies If the giant samurai were revealed to be working with another group it would make sense. If there was any continuity between the epic fantasies it would make sense and flow better. Hell, the ideas seem totally unrelated from the main story except for tenuous connections to the items that they need to collect.
Additionally none of these fantasies add anything to the story. I consider Super Punch to be “Inception if it were written by boners.” In Inception they loosely add to the plots but they are all important action scenes because without the dreams, you can’t tell the story. With Sucker Punch, you can tell the story without the dreams. Sucker Punch is a movie with filler that pander.
And I can say that this isn’t even about the movie being like a video game. Scott Pilgrim was like a video game inspired movie. It told a story that despite flaws, was a very video gamey story that once again incorporated everything in games and made it make sense. It was also fun though, it incorporated all of it’s elements together and the parts are inseparable.
I am not saying that geek films can’t be enjoyed by everyone either – Ironman, Nolan’s Batman movies and a bunch of other comic movies could be named. Men In Black started as a comic. I can’t name a video game inspired movie, as in one based on one, because they are generally bad. Personally I don’t care for the Superman films too much but that is part of the point. Not everyone needs to like everything geek films can be made that all audiences can enjoy.
Zach Snyder may be a geek – I don’t know the guy. He is a corporate tool though. He drugs you up on lowest primal urges when doing what he does. He sticks so close to the original content that there is no room to breathe. I liked Watchmen the first time I saw it. The second time it lessoned and by the third time I had so many issues with it I never want to watch it again. 300 I saw once, laughed at but it left nothing with me. Scott Pilgrim I watched three times in one day, the Hellboy series I love because it is fun and serious at the same time and I’ve seen that like 8 times.
This may all just be me but I don’t care for the stuff Zach Snyder does. His corporatizing, his pandering and the fact that corporations see him as geek bait lead to bad movies. This leads to The Last Airbender. This leads to X-men 3. It leads to Superman Returns which is what we were given with the original Superman movie. Criticizing this though isn’t being untrue to our geekiness. It is showing that we can be mature as well as fans. Don’t throw sticks at people for not liking the stuff you like but also don’t be a silent majority. If you don’t like stuff, feel obligated to take issue but do it respectfully. If people take issue with what you like, respect them to a point. Don’t call them wrong if they have a reasonable point. If they find Sucker Punch to be symbolic in some way that I missed and it would redefine my opinion if I saw it, they have a point. If they just say it is a geek movie and I need to automatically like it they can bugger off so I can read comics.

If you would like my review for Sucker Punch I guess I’d give it a C.

Notes On The Problem Isn’t Zack Snyder. The Problem Is You.
zach snyder is a geek therefore we should like his movies if we are geeks
we apparently attack snyder because we don’t like his stuff?
we feel the need to attack him to feel better?
we are bullying zach snyder because we feel bad about ouselves?
sucker punch has flaws
burdened by heavy soundtrack use
narrative is easy to follow
apparently geeks like David Lynch? never seen the stuff
characters in SP too simplified – yes
luke skywalker too simplified – yes but he is used well
I liked the visuals of Sucker Punch
geeks hate him because he speaks to us – he panders to us
I didn’t care for 300 in general
Mortal Kombat challenges us as players so we get involved in the game.
I have no issue with movies being like video games – I loved Scott Pilgrim
scott pilgrim failed even though it looked like a video game
I don’t want to be pandered to if that is all that it is
guillermo del toro did something with a reason. it had a meaning, it had deep characters, it had great visuals, it had new visuals
we like being isolated?
we are to blame for comics failing as an industry?
I work at a comic shop where we have businessmen come in. I am hella inviting as well.
yes films have fake stuff or wrong stuff – that isn’t an issue unless it is obvious
zach snyder has not been able to show tact
sucker punch isn’t tailor made to me
rape is stupid even in comics. rape is a poorly used tactic to fake drama.
the movie was about 5 decent film ideas that never congealed
a good geek film can be enjoyed by everyone – look at ironman, batman, etc
a lot of early comics are not as good as we think they are.

└ Tags: , , , ,
  Comment